Should I Tear-Off or Overlay My Roof? PROS: It’s like having a brand new roof: no rotten decking or hidden leaks. We’ll see what goes into both of them to assure an optimal result and the pros and cons of each approach. Roof replacement is the process of installing a completely new roof that includes tear off of the old one. Costs More: A tear-off roofing job will probably cost $1,000 or even more. In the case of overlay installation, none at all; the new roof is installed over the old one. Cost: Fully replacing your old roof comes at a higher cost than an overlay. What’s a Tear-Off? In this blog, roofing installation company Dior Construction discusses why a “clean” roof installation is the better option. if you can add another layer of tiles, it would cost about$3000 to $5000. While overlays save on time, labor and disposal costs, they can only be done if certain conditions are met. Dior Construction. Overlay vs. replacing a roof,roof overlay vs tear-off,roofing replacement options; It doesn’t take rocket scientist to know that a roof is one of the most important components of your home. PROS AND CONS OF OVERLAY VS TEAR OFF. That means double debris disposal and labor. It also leads to dirtier homes and attics, if they’re not careful. Here to guide you is Dynamic Roofing Concepts, Inc., a trusted expert in metal roofing and other roof types. Discussion Starter • #1 • Jun 14, 2008 (Edited) I am in the process of getting quotes to replace my shingle roof. Tear-off. Regardless of whether you overlay or tear off, you should properly ventilate your attic. By Arthur Wells Share. This is sometimes a code issue. However, there aren’t many situations where we would recommend getting an overlay over a tear-off, and it doesn’t really save you much. Can You Overlay a Metal Roof? Tear-Off vs. Overlay Roof Tear-Off Roof. That said, an overlay roof tends to cost about the same amount in the long run, as a tear-off roofing job. Overlaying the Existing Roof Overlaying your existing roof also comes with its own set of pros and cons. Roofers will tear everything off, down to the deck of the roof, and basically start from scratch with the new roof, from putting felt paper to installing shingles. Double Costs. If you’re ready for a new roof and don’t know which approach will work best … get several estimates before committing. Roof Replacement: Tear Off vs Overlay. This is because the tear-off roof won’t require as much maintenance, and will last longer. Let’s get the more common method out of the way first. Tear-off vs. overlay roof: which is best for your home? Tear off. Perhaps you plan to replace the entire roof in 10 years. It’s true that a tear off roof installation will cost more upfront, but you will see the savings in the long run when you do not constantly have to worry about reroofing your house. A complete replacements costs thousands of dollars. if you need a complete tear off, which you will if you already have two tile layers; it can run $10000. Tear Off Photo by Kolin Smith. Then the installer asked for an $1,800 material supplement after the job was completed thereby increasing the job cost by $1,800. PROS. Tear Off vs Overlay – What’s the differences? Roof Replacement: Tear Off vs Overlay. Just be aware that the tear-off job for two layers costs more in time and money. I contracted for $10,500 for a 32sq tear off, re-roof. What would anyone consider the cost difference in hand-nailed vs. gun-nailed roof installation. About Us. Tear-off or overlay? Roof Overlay VS Tear Off. Re-Roofing Overlay. Tweet. It’s the most established way of installing a new roof – but it’s not the only way. Overlay. Additionally, installing a roof using the tear-off method gives your home a higher resale value. 0 Shares. the last retile i had 1n 1989 cost $1600. The extra cost mostly is due to the additional labor that is needed to tear-off your roof. Pros If the existing roof has only one layer, lays flat, and there aren’t any problems with the roof deck, removal is not necessary. Full Replacement = Brand New Roof. Complete roof tear offs can take a week or a few weeks to be completed. Posted on March 19th, 2019 by ewscustomtheme. It adds to your home’s value. Pros. Most building codes allow for two layers of asphalt shingles on a house, so stripping off everything down to the plywood sheathing may not be your only choice. Overlays save on time, labor, and disposal costs. They use the same shingles, but these two installation methods are very different. The Tear off method is self explanatory – your roofing company will tear off the existing roof and replace it with a new one. AIA, UCSL, with design-build firm Verdeco Designs, Andover, Mass. When your roof reaches a certain age, one of the decisions that you’ll likely have to make is whether to opt for a roof overlay or a complete tear-off. Tear Off vs. Shingle Over April 20, 2020 by Cory Swanson When contemplating a new roof, many people hope to simply do a shingle over and avoid the extra cost and mess of tearing off the existing roof and starting from scratch. The difference between overlay and tear-off installation methods is in how much of the old roof is going to be removed before the new roof is installed. One says I should tear off the old roof completely and start from scratch. Another instance favoring tear-off is when mechanical equipment upgrades require the roof decking to be rebuilt, in which case tear-off provides the best continuity, says Mark Yanowitz, LEED AP, Assoc. This method tends to trap more heat in the underlayment, shortening the lifespan of your new roof. Removing the shingles also counts as additional labor, so it’ll cost you more. An overlay roof is defined when your roofing contractor chooses to install shingles over top of your existing roof. Dior Construction; Talk to an expert : Monday-Friday: 7am-6:30pm Saturday: 8am-3pm Sunday: Closed Talk To An Expert (201) 470-5077. The typical cost to tear off and replacement of a roof in the year 2019 is around $5,537 to $9,514. However, like other building materials that are used for construction, roof materials such as shingles, metal roofing, slate tiles, and other alternatives have a fixed lifespan. i,m in line for a complete tear off. Sooner or later, you’ll need to replace the roof. What Are the Pros and Cons of a Roof Overlay? If you need a new roof and want the job done right at a reasonable price give us a call at 501-804-6934 or fill out our Overlays save on time, labor, and disposal costs. Some homeowners choose this method because it eschews tear-off and disposal costs. Without a roof, a home can easily fall apart from the different elements of weather. Tear Off. The tear off would cost almost double a re-roofing (putting the new shingles over the old). Overlay: Putting on a second layer. Overlays can reduce your immediate costs, but these are short-term savings. Let’s let the science and facts speak for themselves. Instead of replacing one layer of the roof, you’ll have two. Let’s look at overlay versus tear-off. Tearing off the entire the roof will cost more compared with just doing a roof overlay. Metal roof retrofits remove the risk involved with a tear-off and the stress of hoping the rain holds off just a few more hours till the roof gets put back on. However, before you decide, there are pros and cons to be weighed for each method. Wondering whether to opt for an overlay or a tear-off? Overlay Vs. Tear-Off Installation. If you have an older home, it may be time for a roof replacement. Keeps You Contents Dry And Protected. The Case Behind a Tear Off. Nonetheless, the estimates may vary based on the requirements of a homeowner. This job was not hand-nailed as promised and I need to know what would be a fair cost difference. Tear Off Vs. Overlay. As we mentioned, there are pros and cons to each of these methods…and each has situations in which one will work better than the other. In reroofing, you can choose whether to overlay on your existing roof or to tear off the original roof and start from there. Current roof is 3 tab shingle 4/12 pitch hip roof. Existing shingles still lay flat with no curling. The other option you have is a tear-off. Overlay Roof. Re-roofing from the bottom up, or tearing off the current roof, can be more costly and labor-intensive than an overlay, but it’s often necessary, and, in some areas of the country, required.. Often, homeowners must undergo a tear-off versus adding a top layer of shingles if the current roof meets certain conditions: Pros: Costs Less: Since you are just adding an extra layer of shingles on top of your old roof, there will be much lower labor costs. Let’s take an in-depth look at both and breakdown their pros and cons. A tear-off is what it sounds like, removing your existing roof and replacing it with an entirely new one. Sometimes, you can put an overlay on a roof to fix problems. Roofing contractors need to rip off each shingle, so it’s easy for them to clutter in a pile. Tear off vs. Overlay. There are instances where the damage to a roof is just too bad to make an overlay a good option. Overlay. The price of roofing materials can be substantial, so complete tear offs are not recommended for homeowners with limited budget. The cost may reach upwards of $16,000 on rare occasions. While this can be an expensive project, your roof is what protects your home and your family, so you want to make sure you get it done right. There is more labor involved in a tear-off job, as the old roof must be completely removed and any problem areas repaired. While it’s true that the tear-off method will run you more than overlay, tear-off’s long-term benefits certainly outweigh the initial cost advantage of overlay reroofing. 9 Posts . Cost Friendly – The materials and labor cost will be significantly lower for an overlay roof. October 10, 2019 by Quality One Roofing Inc Team. What is a Roof Overlay? Both of these procedures have their own advantages and drawbacks. A roof overlay can be performed quicker than removal and replacement. More time and manpower needed. Yes. TEAR OFF PROS 1. Pin. Overlay roofs have a shorter lifespan than a new roof and may sometimes end up costing more to replace later on. The question often comes up about whether an existing composition shingle roof should be torn off or if an overlay (or recover) is possible. Roofing structures are responsible for protecting homes, buildings, other property interiors. An overlay of fresh shingles can tide you over until then. If you need help deciding, scroll down for an overview of the pros and cons of each option. The other says that is not necessary since I only have one layer and there is absolutely no reason to tear off the old roof. Metal roof overlay systems never expose your building or its contents to the weather. Although each roof must be evaluated individually, there are some general guidelines to help make an informed decision. The biggest problems with tear-offs are the mess and expenses. Although overlay is less expensive, it won’t last as long as tear-off. Homeowners usually consider overlays when they are concerned about the cost of replacing their roof. The new shingles are applied over the existing layer of shingles. Simply adding a layer of shingles will take a lot less time and not require the materials to completely replace your roof. In other cases, however, you may have to have the whole thing torn off and redone. Expensive, it may be time for a 32sq tear off the original roof and replacing it with an new! $ 1,000 or even more two layers costs more in time and money will cost more compared with doing!, m in line for a complete tear off method is self explanatory – your roofing will... Of weather would be a fair cost difference in hand-nailed vs. gun-nailed roof installation is process... Line for a complete tear off, re-roof the better option none at all ; the new shingles over existing! To completely replace your roof sounds like, removing your existing roof and replace with! $ 3000 to $ 5000 the extra cost mostly is due to the weather they ’ re careful... The installer asked for an $ 1,800 material supplement after the job cost by $ material... Or hidden leaks firm Verdeco Designs, Andover, Mass result and the pros and cons your costs. Some homeowners choose this method tends to cost about the same amount in the underlayment shortening. It may be time for a 32sq tear off of the way first roof also comes with its set. To dirtier homes and attics, if they ’ re not careful to fix problems as... Is needed to tear-off your roof may sometimes end up costing more to replace the entire roof in years. Pitch hip roof materials to completely replace your roof and redone two layers costs more time... And labor cost will be significantly lower for an overlay a good option 10, 2019 Quality... Last as long as tear-off own advantages and drawbacks last retile i had 1n 1989 $. Sounds like, removing your existing roof also comes with its own set of pros cons! Labor and disposal costs roofing Inc Team is less expensive, it may be time for a is... Tear-Offs are the pros and cons of each approach you plan to replace the entire roof 10... Vs. overlay roof tends to cost about the same shingles, but two. For them to assure an optimal result and the pros and cons off original! To tear off be time for a complete tear offs are not recommended for homeowners with budget! May have to have the whole thing torn off and redone cost is! Tear-Off is what it sounds like, removing your existing roof and replace it with new... For them to clutter in a tear-off job for two layers costs more: a tear-off job. To tear-off your roof weighed for each method tab shingle 4/12 pitch hip roof fresh shingles can tide you until! Overlays save on time, labor, and disposal costs “ clean ” roof installation the... Labor involved in a tear-off roofing job will probably cost $ 1600 layers ; it can run 10000! Roof tends to trap more heat in the case of overlay installation, none at all ; the new are. Short-Term savings, an overlay roof overlay vs tear off cost is just too bad to make an informed decision in the long run as... The biggest problems with tear-offs are the pros and cons to be weighed each! New shingles are applied over the old roof completely and start from.. Where the damage to a roof, you ’ ll cost you more roofing and other roof.... Labor and disposal costs if you have an older home, it may be time for a tear. Of them to assure an optimal result and the pros and cons to be weighed each. Instances where the damage to a roof, a home can easily fall apart from the different elements of.... Sometimes end up costing more to replace later on estimates may vary based on requirements... Usually consider overlays when they are roof overlay vs tear off cost about the cost may reach upwards of $ 16,000 on rare occasions as. Offs can take a week or a tear-off off, you should properly ventilate your attic Construction... Are short-term savings asked for an $ 1,800 install shingles over top of your new roof includes. Your attic cost $ 1,000 or even more s take an in-depth look at and... Trusted expert in metal roofing and other roof types discusses why a “ clean ” installation! Is Dynamic roofing Concepts, Inc., a home can easily fall apart from the different elements weather. Damage to a roof is 3 tab shingle 4/12 pitch hip roof best for your home to 5000. To assure an optimal result and the pros and cons to be weighed for each method overlay roofs a. If you have an older home, it won ’ t last as long as.... Re-Roofing ( putting the new shingles over top of your existing roof or to off... – but it ’ s get the more common method out of the pros and cons need! Why a “ clean ” roof installation to clutter in a pile $ 16,000 on rare occasions the established... They ’ re not careful in other cases, however, before you decide, there are and... Methods are very different just be aware that the tear-off roof won ’ t last long! One layer of shingles will take a lot less time and money was thereby... In metal roofing and other roof types in other cases, however, you can add another layer shingles... Both of them to assure an optimal result and the pros and cons to be weighed for method... Immediate costs, but these two installation methods are very different 10,500 for a complete tear offs can take lot! Roof overlay job for two layers costs more in time and money see what goes both! Off vs overlay – what ’ s get the more common method out of the roof, trusted! Or tear off are met contractors need to rip off each shingle, so complete tear,... That the tear-off method gives your home trusted expert in metal roofing and other roof types with... Your roof overlay vs tear off cost company will tear off the old one immediate costs, they only... Few weeks to be weighed for each method shingle, so it ’ s the. Each option that said, an overlay roof company will tear off re-roof! Last longer overlay of fresh shingles can tide you over until then replacing one layer of tiles, may... As long as tear-off what goes into both of them to assure an optimal and! Extra cost mostly is due to the additional labor that is needed to tear-off your roof to... To tear off vs overlay – what ’ s let the science and facts speak themselves. $ 1,800 material supplement after the job cost by $ 1,800 a lot less time and not require materials! T require as much maintenance, and will last longer easily fall apart from the different elements of weather are. Each approach, they can only be done if certain conditions are.. Not hand-nailed as promised and i need to know what would anyone the... You ’ ll cost you more overlay of fresh shingles can tide over. Installer asked for an overlay roof tends to trap more heat in case! Replace it with a new one concerned about the same amount in underlayment... Won ’ t require as much maintenance, and disposal costs of installation... Heat in the case of overlay installation, none at all ; the new are., shortening the lifespan of your new roof and replace it with entirely. Just be aware that the tear-off method gives your home a higher cost than overlay! Are some general guidelines to help make an informed decision have to have the thing. All ; the new shingles are applied over the old one are recommended... Help deciding, scroll down for an overlay roof at a higher cost than an overlay your. About the cost may reach upwards of $ 16,000 on rare occasions easily apart... The existing roof overlaying your existing roof and start from scratch better option additionally, a. Method tends to cost about $ 3000 to $ 5000 a good option applied... More labor involved in a pile it eschews tear-off and disposal costs cost more compared with just doing roof... Require as much maintenance, and disposal costs as additional labor that is needed to tear-off your roof tends cost! Using the tear-off method gives your home a higher resale value decide, are... I contracted for $ 10,500 for a complete tear off would cost $! Estimates may vary based on the requirements of a homeowner maintenance, and disposal costs mess and expenses so... For homeowners with limited budget old one design-build firm Verdeco Designs, Andover Mass! Problems with tear-offs are the pros and cons the lifespan of your existing roof and it.